Fifteen Steps to Successfully Sell Your Old Coins Alongside Visual Guide

1

Gain knowledge about the specific coin. Before proceeding with the sale of a coin, it is imperative to determine its precise identity. Start by identifying the coin's denomination, followed by noting the date and mint mark, which can be found somewhere on the coin. Consequently, you can enter this information into an online search engine, which will assist you in identifying the coin.

• Maintain contact with coin dealers and collectors who can offer their expertise. In instances where you are unable to physically present the coin, capturing clear photographs of both sides and sharing them with online coin collector groups can be valuable.

2

Take notice of the coin's condition. The condition of a coin is a crucial determinant of its value. Examine both sides of the coin thoroughly. Does it appear tarnished or scratched? Remember that the worse the damage, the lower the value of your coin. Additionally, keep an eye out for any printing errors, as these often contribute to increased value.[1]

• Coins are evaluated on a scale ranging from 0 to 70, where 0 represents "Poor" condition and 70 represents "Mint Condition." Coins with a rating of "Good" or 6 exhibit significant wear, while those labeled as "Fine" or 12-15 display a moderate amount of wear.[2]
• Avoid attempting to clean the coin, as this can potentially cause further damage. It is crucial to recognize that coins hold historical significance and collectors prefer them in their original state.

Advertisement

3

Determine the value of the coin. Once you have identified your coin, it is possible to estimate its worth. Numerous online platforms provide lists of current coin values. Alternatively, you can visit a local bookstore and order The Official Red Book, an authoritative and comprehensive guide to coin values.[3]

• Keep in mind that the listed coin values represent the wholesale prices. When selling individual coins, the amount you receive may be lower.

4

Keep an eye on auctions to gain insights into the value of your coin. To obtain more detailed information about coin values, explore recent sale records. Various coins are frequently traded on platforms like Heritage Auctions. Research coins similar to your own to gauge the prices that others are willing to pay for them.[4]

5

Engage the services of a professional appraiser to evaluate your coin collection's value. When dealing with valuable coins or a sizable collection, it is essential to consult an appraiser or dealer. Utilize your local phone directory or online resources to locate a trustworthy and reputable coin appraiser. They will meticulously analyze each coin, authenticate its validity, and provide an accurate valuation.[5]

• Consider checking online reviews from previous clients or consult the Better Business Bureau to ensure the appraiser has a favorable reputation.
• Many reputable dealers are affiliated with organizations like the American Numismatics Association or Professional Coin Grading Service. Utilize these platforms to find reliable appraisers.

6

Categorize coins by their respective values. Varying clientele specializes in distinct coin types. If you plan to sell multiple coins simultaneously, endeavor to segregate them into groups based on their value. Create groups for high-value, medium-value, and low-value coins. The specific method you employ to group the coins is at your discretion, but the simplest approach is to consider their wholesale value.[6]

• You can also consider segregating the coins based on their level of wear, the metal composition, or the place of minting.

1

Engage in conversation with reputable coin dealers. Local coin dealers present themselves as the initial destination when it comes to selling coins. Primarily, you will sell coins of low and medium value here. While visiting a dealer, observe their inventory. If they possess a substantial number of coins composed of the same metal and of comparable quality to the ones you intend to sell, it is highly probable that they will offer a more equitable price.

• Several dealers possess the capacity to handle rare coins, but you typically obtain more money when selling such coins through auctions or private collectors.
• Remember that dealers operate as businesses. To generate profit, they will provide compensation lower than the wholesale price.
• It is advantageous to have multiple dealers evaluate your coins. Maintain politeness as you explore various options.

2

Attend coin shows. Coin shows attract a multitude of buyers and sellers. Seek out individuals engaged in coin transactions involving coins of comparable quality to the ones you intend to sell. Deliberate on a fair selling price, but do not feel coerced to make a hasty decision. While you may not always receive a remarkable offer at a coin show, it offers the opportunity to connect with trustworthy dealers and individuals who can provide valuable guidance.[7]

3

Explore online coin dealers. These websites provide a swift means of selling coins from the comfort of your own home. You can locate platforms willing to purchase both common and rare coins. Once again, be vigilant for dealers specializing in the specific types of coins you plan to sell. A dealer specializing in rare gold coins may not exhibit interest in a wheat penny or buffalo nickel.

• Ensure you capture high-quality photographs of the coins to generate more interest and receive fairer offers. Work in a well-lit environment to maximize the visibility of the lettering and mint marks.

4

Acquire coin collector magazines. Publications such as Numismatic News and Coin World contain advertisements from coin dealers. While these magazines provide valuable information on coin sales, they may also introduce you to your ideal buyer. Obtain a copy from your local coin shop or through online browsing.[8]

• Avoid advertising in your local newspaper as it can make your coins a potential target for thieves, even if you meet in a secure location.

5

Submit your coins to auctions. Coin auctions occur both online and in-person. They occur in various sizes and can be organized locally, regionally, or nationally. Endeavor to find an auction that features a substantial number of coins composed of similar materials as yours, such as copper or silver. Auctions are inherently unpredictable, meaning you may receive less than what a dealer would pay or unexpectedly secure a higher selling price.

• Auctions typically charge both buyers and sellers a fee equal to approximately 10-15% of the final sale price. Account for this when determining your potential earnings from auctioning a coin.
• Online auction platforms like eBay can be used to sell coins, but caution must be exercised to avoid falling victim to scams.[9]

1

Opt for buyers who provide a fair evaluation. Dishonest buyers tend to offer lower prices in hopes of securing a better deal. If possible, observe the person appraising your coins. They should carefully analyze each coin individually. Reject any buyer who offers a fixed price without taking a thorough look at the coins. Do not succumb to pressure from a buyer who insists on an immediate sale.

• Seek out dealers who have positive reviews and are accredited by reputable numismatics organizations.

2

Have multiple buyers assess your coins. Take the time to explore various options to maximize your profits. Allow multiple dealers to evaluate your coins and present their offers. Inform each one that you will "consider their offer and return later." When you are ready to sell, choose the dealer with whom you feel most comfortable doing business.[10]

3

Sell your coin collection as a whole. When dealing with a substantial collection of coins, it is better to keep them as a package deal. Many dealers may only show interest in a few select coins, leaving you with a less valuable collection that is harder to sell. Set a total price for the entire collection and stick to it.

4

Maintain detailed records of your sales. Even a coin that was acquired for free can lead to legal issues. It is likely that your government imposes taxes on any profits made from coin sales. Therefore, it is crucial to keep an extensive record of each sale as well as any coin purchases.[11]

• Familiarize yourself with your local tax laws to understand how to report your income.